As retina fellows, we are excited to enter a field that has undergone tremendous growth and advancement in recent years. With the development of new diagnostic and treatment modalities, we have been given the tools to provide the most up-to-date care for a wide range of retina disease, both in the clinic and the OR. After speaking with a close friend from residency who has chosen to practice ophthalmology in a developing country, which is something most of us will never experience, we are reminded that the treatment of retinal disease drastically differs in different in parts of the world. Hearing his stories has affected our approach toward treating patients with retinal disorders. We no longer take for granted easy access to the technologies that we use on a daily basis. Below, John Cropsey, MD, and Ben Roberts, MD, both of whom are currently practicing at Tenwek Mission Hospital, Kenya, share their experiences.
— Paul S. Baker, MD; Allen Chiang, MD; and Eugene A. Milder, MD
Q: How did you decide to practice ophthalmology in
the developing world?
John Cropsey, MD: I grew up in Togo, in West Africa,
at a mission hospital that exposed me to the great medical
needs of sub-Saharan Africa. There was such a lack of
eye care in the 1980s and 1990s that my father, a general
surgeon, was trained to perform cataract and glaucoma
surgery. My father and two other missionary surgeons
independently told me that if they were to do it over
again, they would become ophthalmologists to serve in
the developing world. In addition, God has shown me so
much love, mercy, and grace, that I am compelled to love
my neighbor as myself. My strong faith has led me to
make neighbors in sub-Saharan Africa at Tenwek Mission
Hospital, Kenya.
Ben Roberts, MD: I made several trips to developing countries beginning in college and saw the great need for quality care and training in other parts of the world. My first trip was with a group of ophthalmologists who went to Jamaica to work in a 2-week clinic and surgical camp. After several years of ophthalmology exposure by taking these trips, I decided to pursue ophthalmology residency training and devote a good portion of my time to medical missions.
Q: Of the patients you see, what percentage present
with retinal disease?
Dr. Cropsey: Tenwek Mission Hospital is one of only a
handful of referral centers in East Africa that have the
resources to treat retinal pathology. Approximately 20%
of our cases are retina.
Q: What types of retinal pathology do you see most
often in your clinic?
Dr. Roberts: The majority of retinal pathology that we
see stems from diabetic retinopathy. Diabetes is rapidly on
the rise in developing countries, particularly in East Africa
where I spend most of my time. Most patients present
with very advanced proliferative disease secondary to
many years of poorly controlled diabetes. The second
most common retinal pathology is trauma. The majority of the population in East Africa survives by working outdoors,
either farming or caring for livestock. Few, if any,
wear safety protection when working in risky environments.
In general, most patients have a delayed presentation
compared with patients in the United States.
Q: What office-based treatment modalities are available
to you?
Dr. Cropsey: We are fortunate at Tenwek to be one of
only three or four centers in all of Kenya, with a population
of 38 million, that have the ability to perform
advanced, office-based treatment for retinal pathology.
In terms of diagnostics, we have fluorescein angiography,
digital fundus photography, and automated visual
field testing. Unfortunately, we do not have optical
coherence tomography, which would be helpful. In our
hospital, we have argon laser and bevacizumab (Avastin,
Genentech). There is little difference in how we treat
patients compared with the United States, although we
charge much less. For example, panretinal photocoagulation
costs a patient the equivalent of $6.
Q: For what retinal diseases do you intervene surgically?
Dr. Roberts: We perform surgery for proliferative diabetic
retinopathy, trauma, retinal detachments, and to a
lesser degree macular hole surgery.
Q: What surgical tools do you have at your disposal?
Dr. Cropsey: Very few people in sub-Saharan Africa
have access to retinal treatment, particularly surgical
intervention. In Kenya, there are only two centers with
surgical capability for the general population. At
Tenwek, we have an Accurus (Alcon Laboratories, Inc.)
and a Zeiss microscope (Carl Zeiss Meditec, Dublin, CA)
that allow us to perform nearly any retinal surgery that
one could do in the United States. We perform all of
our surgeries using a contact lens. We also have
endolaser, SF6, heavy liquid, and silicone oil at our disposal.
Because we have so few retina specialists in this
region, I am performing retina surgeries as a general
ophthalmologist 1 year out of residency and with no
formal retina fellowship training.
Q: How would you characterize the treatment of retinal
detachments in the developing world?
Dr. Cropsey: The vast majority of patients with retinal
detachments in sub-Saharan Africa will never have
access to a retina specialist, and so they go untreated.
For example, physicians in the two eye care centers that
are responsible for the majority of retinal care in Kenya
performed 800 retina surgeries last year for a population
of 38 million. Kenya likely has the most advanced
eye care in sub-Saharan Africa outside of South Africa.
Most countries in this region have no retina specialists,
and the patients who present to us almost always have
chronic detachments with proliferative vitreoretinopathy
(PVR) and a poor prognosis. In my year at Tenwek,
I have had only four patients present within the first
month of retinal detachment.
Dr. Roberts: Most retinal detachments present late and require combined treatment modalities such as pars plana vitrectomy, scleral buckle, and silicone oil.
Q: What are the major obstacles to treating retinal
disease in the developing world?
Dr. Cropsey: The first and foremost obstacle is a lack
of retina specialists. There are very few ophthalmology
residency programs in sub-Saharan Africa and no retina
fellowships. The second is the lack of equipment. For
example, Uganda's only retina specialist does not have
access to a vitrectomy machine. Third is poverty. It is
very difficult for poor patients in rural areas to find a
general eye care provider, and if, by some miracle, they
do find a retina specialist, they often cannot afford care.
I saw a man today from Nairobi who had been quoted a
price of 200,000 Ks ($2,500) for a retinal detachment
repair by a retina specialist at one of the charitable eye
units. When a majority of the population is living on
the equivalent of $1 a day, this amounts to almost 7
years of wages. Would you pay that amount to have
surgery? What if it meant you would not be able to feed
your children or send them to school? At Tenwek, we
are able to provide retinal care to the poor only because of significant subsidies from charitable organizations
and churches in the United States.
Dr. Roberts: Having disposable supplies such as tubing, vitrectomy cutters, and blades presents obstacles because nothing is wasted in the developing world, and instruments and supplies are often used longer than they are designed for, purely out of necessity. We are careful, however, not to compromise sterility and patient safety.
Q: How do you best allocate limited time and
resources to treat patients with retinal disease?
Dr. Cropsey: This has been one of my major issues in
adjusting to life in Africa. Because of the immense need
there, I have had to work long hours to take care of all
the patients that come to me, and it is has become
physically and emotionally unsustainable. In the past
few weeks, I have decided to drastically limit the number
of retina cases that I am willing to take on because
other pathology requires much less time to treat and I
am able to achieve better outcomes.
Dr. Roberts: There is definitely a learning curve in the art of allocation. For instance, patients presenting with chronic retinal detachments are counseled extensively before proceeding with surgery. I also take into account the presence and severity of bilateral retinal disease. If a patient presents with 20/20 vision in one eye and hand motion vision in the other eye with a chronic retinal detachment, I am less likely to attempt repair, knowing that it will not offer any significant functional change for that person's vision. Alternatively, if a patient presents with bilateral advanced PVR and vitreous hemorrhage, I am likely to offer surgery because this scenario has potentially good visual outcomes.
Q: How can a retina physician who is interested in
humanitarian work contribute to patient care in the
developing world?
Dr. Roberts: There are several ways of helping.
Physicians can help by contributing financially to
organizations or individuals who are actively providing
quality care in the developing world. Another way to
help is to collect supplies that go unused stateside and
send them to these organizations or individuals.
Further, retina specialists are always welcome to serve
at one of these locations for a few weeks, months, or
even an indefinite period of time if such a situation is
allowable. Teaching others and transferring skills to
African nationals or US expatriates who are providing
eye care in the developing world is another welcome
way to help.
If you have equipment that is no longer needed, particularly lasers and vitrectomy machines that are of high quality, World Medical Mission and Christian Blind Mission (see inset above for the Web addresses for these organizations) are examples of organizations that can facilitate placing equipment where it is needed.
I encourage anyone who has an interest in volunteering to make a trip to where your skills and resources can restore vision to someone who otherwise would not receive help. The experiences and blessings that result from a service mission far outweigh any sacrifice of time or resources needed to participate.
Ben Roberts, MD, is a member of the Retina Consultants of Alabama in Birmingham. He has spent significant time at Tenwek Mission Hospital in Bomet, Kenya, and will be returning to Tenwek in the summer of 2011.
John Cropsey, MD, is currently in his second year of practice at Tenwek Mission Hospital. He moved to Kenya after graduating from the ophthalmology residency program at Wills Eye Institute, Thomas Jefferson University, in Philadelphia.
Paul S. Baker, MD; Allen Chiang, MD; and Eugene A. Milder, MD, are second-year vitreoretinal fellows at Wills Eye Institute, Thomas Jefferson University, and members of the Retina Today Editorial Board. Dr. Baker may be reached at pbakerny@yahoo.com; Dr. Chiang may be reached at allen_chiang@alumni.brown.edu; and Dr. Milder may be reached at genemilder@gmail.com.